Classify three traverse books before computing closure
Three short route descriptions have different controls. Identify which checks are possible and calculate the residuals where the evidence allows.
On this page
Assign the three booksAnswer key for OrchardAnswer key for CanalAnswer key for TrailTeaching notesAll three notebooks end with a coordinate. Only two contain enough information to test where that endpoint should be. Put away the calculator until you have classified the routes. A numerical endpoint is a result. A closure test also needs an independent expectation for that endpoint.
Assign the three books
Each example uses horizontal metres on the same local grid, with no grid reduction required. The signed totals below are sums of the recorded course displacements. A positive ΔN means north, a positive ΔE means east.
| Book | Start N, E | Intended endpoint | Sum ΔN, ΔE | Measured travel |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Orchard | 400, 650 | Return to marked start | +0.012, −0.016 | 240.000 m |
| Canal | 100, 200 | Mark at N 160, E 280 | +59.982, +80.024 | 180.000 m |
| Trail | 300, 100 | Newly set peg with no independent coordinates | +12.000, +35.000 | 87.000 m |
For each book, find the computed endpoint and identify the information that would define a positional residual. Where possible, give signed residuals as computed minus intended, followed by linear misclosure and the relative precision denominator. For the uncheckable book, state one useful quantity you can still compute.
Answer key for Orchard
The intended displacement of a loop is zero. The computed endpoint is N 400.012, E 649.984. Relative to the marked start this point lies 0.012 m north and 0.016 m west. Its gap is √(0.012² + 0.016²) = 0.020 m. The measured travel divided by the gap is 240 / 0.020 = 12,000, conventionally expressed as 1:12,000.
Students should show the two signed components even if they recognize a scaled 3–4–5 triangle. The signs would be needed to describe the direction of the discrepancy. The square root used for magnitude cannot recover them.
Answer key for Canal
Canal is a link ending on different known control. The intended displacement is +60 m north and +80 m east. Add the observed sums to the start and obtain N 159.982, E 280.024. Relative to the known terminal mark, the computed endpoint falls 0.018 m south and 0.024 m east. Its gap is 0.030 m, giving 180 / 0.030 = 6,000, or 1:6,000.
A number near 100 m in the misclosure column means the student measured back toward the wrong point. The control-to-control straight distance is exactly 100 m because 60, 80 and 100 form a right triangle. Neither that chord nor the observed start-to-end chord is the residual at the terminal control.
Answer key for Trail
The computed peg is N 312.000, E 135.000. Its displacement from the start has magnitude √(12² + 35²) = 37.000 m. The survey traveled 87.000 m along its successive legs. Those two numbers describe route geometry. They supply no independent coordinate of the peg. Reporting 87/37 as a precision denominator would compare travel length with net advance and tell you nothing about closure.
Students can propose a repeat traverse, a tie to independently established control, or a separate setup that measures the peg relative to known controls. Ask them to say what the check would predict and which observations remain independent.
Teaching notes
Mark the route classification before scoring arithmetic. A student who correctly explains why Trail has no positional check has answered one of the central questions even without a decimal result. For an extension, give the Trail peg independent coordinates of N 311.970, E 135.040. The computed-minus-known residual becomes +0.030 m north and −0.040 m east. Its magnitude is 0.050 m and the new ratio is 1:1,740. Adding one independent fact changed which question the data could answer.