Share seven arcseconds across four whole-second entries
Allocate a small angular correction using an explicit rounding rule, prove the corrected sum, and compare it with exact fractional-second balancing.
On this page
Original angles and the exercise ruleWorked sum and allocationExplain the difference between the two ledgersTeaching notes and extensionA four-station interior-angle sum is seven seconds high. Dividing the excess equally gives 1.75 seconds per angle. The recording form has no fractional-second column. Rounding all four corrections to two seconds would remove eight. Your task is to produce a ledger that preserves the observations and balances exactly under a stated classroom rule.
Original angles and the exercise rule
The four angles belong to a simple closed planar quadrilateral. The instructor has assigned the following whole-second allocation rule for this exercise. Give each station the same integer base correction. Allocate any remaining single seconds in station order A, B, C, D. This ordering is supplied solely to make the exercise reproducible. Other project procedures can use sight lengths or observation weights.
| Station | Observed interior angle |
|---|---|
| A | 88°15′12″ |
| B | 92°43′17″ |
| C | 87°26′29″ |
| D | 91°35′09″ |
First calculate the observed sum by adding degrees, minutes and seconds separately and carrying units. Write the theoretical sum, the observed-minus-theoretical excess and the required total correction. Then fill one column with equal fractional corrections and another with the specified whole-second corrections.
Worked sum and allocation
The degrees sum to 358, minutes to 119 and seconds to 67. Carry 60 seconds into one minute to obtain 358°120′07″. Carry 120 minutes into two degrees. The observed total is 360°00′07″. The quadrilateral requires 360°, so the signed total correction is −7″.
The exact equal correction is −1.75″ per station. Under the classroom integer rule allocate −1″ to each station first. Four seconds have been removed. Remove the last three seconds at A, B and C, one per station. D keeps its −1″ correction.
| Station | Whole-second correction | Adjusted angle |
|---|---|---|
| A | −2″ | 88°15′10″ |
| B | −2″ | 92°43′15″ |
| C | −2″ | 87°26′27″ |
| D | −1″ | 91°35′08″ |
The adjusted seconds total 60. With the original 119 minutes that gives 120 minutes, and the original 358 degrees plus two gives 360°. Another transparent check is to sum the corrections to −7″ and add that directly to the observed total. Both routes recover the theoretical sum.
Explain the difference between the two ledgers
The fractional solution would give A seconds of 10.25, B of 15.25, C of 27.25 and D of 7.25. Each angular observation shares equally in the policy correction. Display all four fractional results to the nearest whole second and their displayed seconds sum to 59. The rounded display appears one second low even though the exact fractional values balance perfectly.
The integer ledger instead makes the distributed quantities themselves whole seconds and balances their sum. The choice affects subsequent carried bearings, particularly at intermediate stations. If a student reallocates the extra seconds to a different set of three stations, the total can remain correct. Ask whether that student followed the prescribed tie-breaking rule before comparing individual answers.
Teaching notes and extension
Invite students to repeat the procedure for an observed deficit of seven seconds. The magnitudes of the allocation stay the same and the signs become positive. Then try a +3″ excess spread over five stations. Under the same ordering rule three angles receive −1″ and two receive zero. An angle with a zero allocated correction is still part of the observation set.
Have each student add a short report line naming both the equal-weight assumption and the remainder policy. Mathematical closure alone does not establish the adequacy of the observations. If an instrument setup were unreliable, the crew would investigate it before distributing the discrepancy. The purpose here is narrower and measurable: a reader should be able to reproduce every adjusted angle from the raw column and the written allocation rule.