Survey WorkbookA field manual for survey instructionGet COGO
Field observations

A level-book puzzle: recover the missing foresight from a return run

Use two independently supplied benchmark elevations and a reverse run to test a missing entry and explain what the arithmetic cannot recover.

On this pageWorksheetRun the forward arithmeticReduce the independent returnDecide what the evidence supports

The last foresight on a level-book copy is illegible. You know both benchmark elevations and can calculate exactly what that reading would need to be for a perfect close. Is that the reading the crew observed? Work the transfer in both directions before you answer.

Worksheet

All values are metres. Benchmark A has accepted elevation 14.850 m and B has accepted elevation 15.235 m on the same local datum. TP-F and TP-R are different stable turning points. Entries are center-wire readings. In each row, observe the backsight on the named start, move to the named end by foresight and compute the elevation there.

Direction Setup Start Backsight End Foresight
Forward F1 A 1.237 TP-F 0.758
Forward F2 TP-F 0.966 B unreadable
Return R1 B 1.118 TP-R 1.385
Return R2 TP-R 0.884 A 0.998

Determine the forward elevation of TP-F. Solve for the missing foresight that would make the forward run close exactly on B. Reduce the return run starting at the accepted B elevation, and report its closing difference at A. Separately decide what you would enter in the field record if no original instrument file or legible field page could be recovered.

Run the forward arithmetic

The first HI is 14.850 + 1.237 = 16.087 m. TP-F lies at 16.087 − 0.758 = 15.329 m. The second HI is 15.329 + 0.966 = 16.295 m. To finish exactly at 15.235 m, the foresight would have to be 16.295 − 15.235 = 1.060 m.

Check the calculation by differences. The first setup gains 0.479 m. The benchmarks differ by +0.385 m, so the second setup must lose 0.094 m for an exact match. A backsight of 0.966 and foresight of 1.060 differ by −0.094 m. These two calculations agree because they solve the same condition. Neither supplies the lost observation.

Reduce the independent return

Starting on B, the first return setup changes elevation by 1.118 − 1.385 = −0.267 m. TP-R lies at 14.968 m. The second setup changes elevation by 0.884 − 0.998 = −0.114 m, giving a computed A of 14.854 m. Relative to accepted A, the return closes +0.004 m high. Across the two setups, the observed return change is −0.381 m.

If you assumed that the forward observation measured the exact opposite of the return change, the forward change would be +0.381 m and the calculated foresight would become 1.064 m. The two hypothetical answers differ by 0.004 m. The return measured a separate route through TP-R with its own observational uncertainty. It cannot identify which, if either, was actually booked on F2.

Decide what the evidence supports

Mark the F2 foresight as missing in the recovered copy. Record the two diagnostic calculations on a separate worksheet and identify their assumptions. Search for the original image, recorder file or another contemporaneous copy. If a dependable observation remains unavailable, follow the exercise instruction to exclude the incomplete forward run and specify the reobservation needed.

The common grading error is to fill the gap with 1.060 m and then cite the resulting perfect closure as proof of quality. That closure was an imposed condition. Another is to cancel the two turning points as though the crews observed the same object. Name each turning point and keep the runs separate.

For discussion, suppose a clear image later reveals 1.062 m. The recovered forward elevation would be 15.233 m, closing −0.002 m at B. The class can now compare two actual observed runs. Ask students to describe how the status of that last number changed when an observation replaced an inference.

References

Practice the same traverse in COGO