Survey WorkbookA field manual for survey instructionGet COGO
Field observations

Area by perpendicular offsets when the baseline intervals are unequal

Estimate the area of a measured strip from irregularly spaced offsets and quantify the effect of an extra observation at a bend.

On this pageSketch before calculatingWeight the observations by the ground they representAdd the field observation where it changes the edgeGrade the drawing as well as the answer

A crew records offsets at baseline stations 0, 4, 10 and 18 m. One student averages all four offsets and multiplies by 18. Another draws three trapezoids with different widths. Which estimate represents the boundary drawn as straight segments between the observations?

Sketch before calculating

The baseline is straight. Each offset is horizontal, perpendicular to the baseline, and measured to the same physical edge on the right when looking in the direction of increasing station. Straight perpendicular end lines at stations 0 and 18 close the strip. Assume linear change of offset between adjacent measured stations for the initial estimate.

Baseline station, m Right offset, m
0.00 1.20
4.00 2.00
10.00 3.40
18.00 2.20

Calculate the area of each trapezoid and the total estimated plan area. Compare that result with the proposed unweighted average of all four readings. Next, suppose a fifth shot at station 14.00 has offset 3.30 m. Recalculate the affected interval and explain which answer you would send to the person preparing an area sketch.

Weight the observations by the ground they represent

From station 0 to 4, the average of the two edge offsets is (1.20 + 2.00) / 2 = 1.60 m. Multiplying by the 4.00 m interval gives 6.40 m². From 4 to 10, the mean is (2.00 + 3.40) / 2 = 2.70 m, applied across 6.00 m for 16.20 m². From 10 to 18, the mean is (3.40 + 2.20) / 2 = 2.80 m, applied across 8.00 m for 22.40 m².

The three pieces sum to 45.00 m². The unweighted mean of all four readings is 2.20 m, giving 39.60 m² when multiplied by 18.00 m. It gives every observation the same influence despite the different interval widths and the fact that the interior readings contribute to two neighboring intervals. The difference is 5.40 m² for this dataset.

An independent coordinate check uses station as the along-axis coordinate and offset as the perpendicular coordinate. Walk the polygon from (0,0) to (18,0), then through the four observed edge points in reverse station order and close at the start. A coordinate area calculation gives the same 45.00 m² for this piecewise straight polygon.

Add the field observation where it changes the edge

Under the first estimate, the boundary at station 14 would have interpolated to 2.80 m because 14 is halfway from 10 to 18. The measured value 3.30 m lies 0.50 m farther from the baseline. Replace the 8 m trapezoid with two 4 m pieces. From 10 to 14, area is 4 × (3.40 + 3.30) / 2 = 13.40 m². From 14 to 18, area is 4 × (3.30 + 2.20) / 2 = 11.00 m².

Their combined 24.40 m² increases the total to 47.00 m². Check the incremental change as a triangle above the originally interpolated segment, 8.00 × 0.50 / 2 = 2.00 m². The edge between shots is still modeled by straight segments. Additional observations at genuine breaks could change the estimate again.

Grade the drawing as well as the answer

Require a station scale, signed side, offset unit, edge order and closure to the baseline. An answer that treats the offsets as sloping tape distances has introduced a different geometric assumption. Likewise, averaging absolute offsets from both sides of a baseline would describe a different strip.

The final sketch should identify all actual shots and distinguish them from interpolated segments. Ask the student where they would take one more field shot if the visible edge bends sharply near station 7. Their reasoning should follow the shape and the uncertainty between measured points, rather than a desire to make the station list look evenly spaced.

References

Practice the same traverse in COGO