Two missing quadrants can produce two closed figures
Work both interpretations of a partly legible bearing book, then choose the independent observation that distinguishes the two solutions.
On this page
Read the surviving field entriesWorked answer for the course sumsNotice what shape these particular observations makeTeaching notesRain has blurred the final letters of two quadrant bearings in a training field book. One student restores the suffixes, runs the loop and gets zero misclosure. Another chooses the opposite pair and also gets zero. Use coordinate arithmetic to decide whether either student has proved the missing letters.
Read the surviving field entries
Start at A with N 800.000 m, E 1200.000 m. The four straight horizontal courses are in travel order. An unknown suffix is marked with a question mark. The printed north or south prefix remains legible.
| Leg | Surviving direction | Length |
|---|---|---|
| A–B | Due north | 24 m |
| B–C | N 30° ? | 40 m |
| C–D | S 30° ? | 40 m |
| D–A | Due south | 24 m |
First predict how many combinations of E and W are possible. Compute the north and east totals for all four. For each interpretation that closes, give the coordinate of C. Then determine which one fits a separate signed coordinate check, C lies at E 1220.000 m. Assume the independent tie uses the same local grid as A.
Worked answer for the course sums
Each 40 m oblique course contributes 40 cos 30° = 34.641016 m along the north–south axis and 40 sin 30° = 20.000 m along the east–west axis. The north prefix of B–C and south prefix of C–D make their north components cancel. The first and last cardinal legs cancel too. The north total is therefore zero for every possible assignment of the missing suffixes.
| B–C suffix | C–D suffix | East sum | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| E | E | +40 m | Endpoint lies east of A |
| E | W | 0 | Closes |
| W | E | 0 | Closes |
| W | W | −40 m | Endpoint lies west of A |
B is N 824.000, E 1200.000 in all cases. With an eastward B–C, C lies at N 858.641016, E 1220.000. With a westward B–C, C lies at N 858.641016, E 1180.000. The two closing interpretations put C 40 m apart. Their common zero endpoint discrepancy cannot tell you which side of the initial line contains C.
Notice what shape these particular observations make
The two 40 m courses in either closing interpretation run in exactly opposite directions. D returns to B. The final south leg retraces B–A. Each closed figure is an out-and-back path with zero enclosed area. This is intentional in the exercise. A loop can return exactly to its starting point even though the field entries never enclose a parcel.
An independent northing of C would be identical in both solutions. An independent distance B–C would also agree with both, since they use the same 40 m side. Even the straight distance from A to C is equal in the two mirror images. The supplied signed easting distinguishes them. It supports N 30° E for B–C and S 30° W for C–D. A reliable observed direction to C would provide another way to remove the ambiguity.
Teaching notes
Ask half the class to solve using a sketch and the other half using signed components. Compare the two methods at the moment D returns to B. Some students will recognize the path is doubled before doing any arithmetic. Others will discover the repeated coordinates in their results. Both have found a geometric test stronger than merely reading the final zero.
If the control easting were missing, the appropriate conclusion would be two compatible interpretations with supporting evidence still required. Award credit for retaining the question marks in the observation column and labeling the chosen suffixes as reconstructed. A clean table of computed coordinates is valuable only if a future reader can tell which details were actually observed.