Survey WorkbookA field manual for survey instructionGet COGO
Field observations

Three-wire leveling exercise: find the reading to reobserve

Use upper, middle and lower rod readings to catch an inconsistent observation and compare sight lengths before reducing a level setup.

On this pageObservation sheetTest the readings separately from their sight lengthsComplete the reduction after a new observationMarking notes

The arithmetic mean of the two outer wires on one rod is 1.461 m. The middle wire was booked as 1.416 m. Would you transpose the last two digits, keep the booked value or return to the rod? This exercise asks you to distinguish a strong diagnostic clue from a replacement measurement.

Observation sheet

Use the following simulated readings on an upright metric staff. The telescope has symmetric stadia hairs, a stadia interval factor of 100 and a negligible additive constant for this exercise. The instrument is level. Upper and lower refer to the larger and smaller staff readings in this table. The example comparison rule calls for a new observation if the booked center differs from the mean of the outer readings by more than 0.002 m. This is an exercise rule, not an agency specification.

Sight Point Upper, m Center, m Lower, m
Backsight BM-6 1.683 1.493 1.303
Foresight TP-9 1.638 1.416 1.284

The benchmark elevation is 62.400 m. First, calculate the mean outer-wire reading for both sights. Then calculate the signed center-minus-mean differences. Find the approximate horizontal sight distances and their difference. Finally, write what you would do with the original foresight before using the observations to transfer an elevation.

Test the readings separately from their sight lengths

On BM-6, the outer mean is (1.683 + 1.303) / 2 = 1.493 m. The booked center agrees to the displayed millimetre. The staff intercept is the upper reading minus the lower, 0.380 m. Multiplying by 100 gives an estimated distance of 38.0 m. The mean and the difference use the same pair of readings but answer different questions.

On TP-9 the outer mean is (1.638 + 1.284) / 2 = 1.461 m. The booked center differs by 1.416 − 1.461 = −0.045 m. The intercept of 0.354 m gives a distance of 35.4 m. The backsight is therefore about 2.6 m longer than the foresight. A sensible distance estimate does not validate the center reading; the center was not used to calculate that estimate.

The 45 mm disagreement exceeds the classroom limit. The digits look like a transposition, but the field book cannot prove which wire was misread. Preserve the original set and repeat the observation in accordance with the procedure for the exercise. In an actual job, the approved instrument and field method determine which readings must be repeated and how accepted means are computed.

Complete the reduction after a new observation

For the second part, the instructor supplies a new, independently observed TP-9 set: upper 1.639 m, center 1.462 m, lower 1.285 m. Its outer mean is 1.462 m and the center discrepancy is zero at the recorded precision. Using accepted center-wire readings for this exercise, the height of instrument is 62.400 + 1.493 = 63.893 m. The transferred elevation of TP-9 is 63.893 − 1.462 = 62.431 m.

If you had used the suspect 1.416 m foresight, the resulting elevation would have been 62.477 m. It differs from the accepted result by +0.046 m. This figure differs slightly from the original 0.045 m diagnostic discrepancy because the replacement was a fresh observation. The distinction is a useful check on whether your solution silently manufactured a reading.

Marking notes

Award a separate mark for identifying the failed reading, showing the sign of the discrepancy and explaining why reobservation is needed. A solution that substitutes 1.461 m without a field decision has answered an arithmetic question while skipping the observation question. Require units on distances and rod readings even though both use metres.

For an extension, ask whether a perfectly agreeing center and outer mean proves that the rod was held on the correct turning point. All three wires could have been read consistently on the wrong surface. Have the student state which field notes would help detect that particular mistake.

References

Practice the same traverse in COGO