Survey WorkbookA field manual for survey instructionGet COGO
Mapping and measurement

Plot a notched parcel and recover its area two ways

Use six grid coordinates to draw an L-shaped figure, calculate its area and perimeter, and locate a coordinate-order error that the area check misses.

On this pagePlot the stations before choosing a formulaWork the area by adding and subtractingCheck the perimeter and orientationDiagnose a convincing wrong answer

A parcel with a rectangular notch can have exactly the same enclosed area after its coordinate axes are swapped. A correct numerical area therefore cannot certify a correct drawing. In this exercise you will grade both the plan and the arithmetic. The synthetic coordinates use metres on a local rectangular grid. They describe a classroom figure and carry no boundary authority.

Plot the stations before choosing a formula

Corner in walking order Easting Northing
A 500 100
B 552 100
C 552 118
D 532 118
E 532 144
F 500 144

Use the lower-left corner of your paper as E 500, N 100 and draw east right, north up. A convenient drawing scale is 1 cm to 10 m. Mark and label the vertices in their listed order, then return from F to A. Before computing the answer, identify which side contains a notch and write the direction from A to B. These observations will be used to check the final drawing.

Work the area by adding and subtracting

From the bottom of the figure to northing 118, the parcel spans 52 m east to west. This lower rectangle has area 52 × 18 = 936 m². Between northing 118 and 144, the width is only 32 m. The upper rectangle contributes 32 × 26 = 832 m². Adding the two gives an enclosed area of 1,768 m².

For an independent decomposition, draw the enclosing rectangle, 52 m wide and 44 m high. Its total area is 2,288 m². The missing northeast corner measures 20 m by 26 m, or 520 m². Subtracting 520 gives 1,768 m² again. Each decomposition should be visible on the plot. A number with no indication of the notch makes it hard to distinguish understanding from a coincidental result.

Check the perimeter and orientation

Walking the six legs in order gives 52 m east, 18 m north, 20 m west, 26 m north, 32 m west and 44 m south. Their magnitudes sum to 192 m. The signed east-west changes total 52 − 20 − 32 = 0, and the signed north-south changes total 18 + 26 − 44 = 0. Both sums should vanish for this exact coordinate figure.

The enclosing rectangle also has perimeter 192 m. Removing this particular corner replaces 20 m of horizontal boundary and 26 m of vertical boundary with the same two lengths in another location. Consequently the perimeter alone cannot distinguish the full rectangle from the intended shape. The area calculations and notched sketch supply evidence the perimeter cannot.

Diagnose a convincing wrong answer

Give a classmate a copy in which every easting and northing is swapped and the axes are still labeled east and north. The two decompositions will still give the same area, and every leg length will still be correct. However, A to B now travels north instead of east. The independent direction check from the station sheet catches what the measurements missed.

Ask the class to explain why subtracting a convenient coordinate origin before plotting is safe. Each new local coordinate is the original minus the same offset on its axis, so all differences, distances and areas are unchanged. Subtracting different offsets at different corners changes the figure. Finally, award marks for station order, correct orientation, a labeled notch, two consistent area arguments and the signed closure check. Students who draw from the coordinate pairs rather than their headings should be asked to show the first leg direction explicitly.

References

Practice the same traverse in COGO